The loan charge and contractor loan schemes
How employee benefit trust and contractor loan schemes worked, the 2019 loan charge that taxed the loans as income, the reviews, and the 2026 settlement scheme.
2002–2026
REVIEWED 2026-09-05
From the early 2000s a part of the contracting market was paid through arrangements that were not salary and not dividends. The worker received a small salary and the balance as a loan from an offshore trust or a company, on terms under which the loan was never expected to be repaid. Promoters sold the schemes as lawful, often with counsel's opinion, and paid agencies and umbrellas to recommend them. Tens of thousands of contractors used them.
The response
HMRC's position throughout was that the loans were disguised remuneration and taxable as income when paid. The disguised remuneration legislation of 2011 stopped new arrangements of the original kind, and the Finance Act 2014 gave HMRC the power to demand disputed tax up front through accelerated payment notices. Many contractors received notices for years of income at once. Many others were never contacted at all, because the promoter had disappeared and the individual did not appear on HMRC's radar until the loan charge.
The loan charge
Announced in the 2016 Budget and effective on 5 April 2019, the loan charge treated every outstanding disguised remuneration loan made since 1999 as income of the 2018-19 tax year, taxing the accumulated balance at once and at that year's rates. The scale of the resulting bills, the retrospective reach and the reports of suicides among those affected produced a campaign that has not stopped. The Morse review of December 2019 moved the start date to 2010 and removed the charge for years HMRC could have pursued but had not. A second independent review reported in 2025.
The 2026 settlement scheme
Regulations made on 14 July 2026 created a settlement scheme that came into force on 5 August. Every bill is reduced by £5,000, with a further reduction of up to £10,000 for each year a scheme was used, capped at £70,000; late payment interest is removed; payment can be spread over five years or longer. HMRC says most people will see their bills at least halved and around a third could pay nothing. Letters went out from late July, each with a named caseworker and at least 90 days to respond. The contractor bodies and campaigners regard the terms as an improvement and the underlying charge as unfair, particularly for those who settled earlier on worse terms.
For anyone affected
Read the letter, obtain the figures, and take advice before the acceptance period ends. The scheme's terms are the best offered so far and will not be improved by waiting. The articles below cover the schemes, the notices, the charge and the reviews as they happened.
- 4 SEP 2026Loan charge settlement letters go out with the promise that a third will pay nothingHMRC has begun writing to thousands of people with outstanding loan charge liabilities under the settlement scheme that came into force on 5 August…BUSINESS
- 21 JUL 2025Draft Finance Bill hands HMRC criminal powers over tax-avoidance promotersThe government's Legislation Day package aims squarely at the marketed schemes that have left thousands of contractors nursing unexpected tax bills…BUSINESS
- 26 FEB 2025MPs tell Reeves the loan charge review is drawn too narrowly to reach contractorsThe government's new inquiry examines only how contractors settle, not whether they should have to, and cross-party MPs want to know why.POLITICS
- 21 JUN 2022Call for evidence on 'Loan Charge Scandal'A Parliamentary group has called for evidence from advisers following 'harrowing evidence' supplied by individuals on the Loan Charge controversy.BUSINESS
- 25 MAY 2022HMRC wins disguised remuneration tax avoidance caseThe Court of Appeal found in favour of HMRC's right to collect unpaid income tax directly from a contractor who arranged to be paid via loans from…BUSINESS
- 20 DEC 2021Government move on umbrella sectorGovernment move on umbrella companies is an opportunity to end the disguised remuneration problem, according to a pressure group.BUSINESS
- 12 AUG 2021TUC calls to ban umbrella companiesCalls by trade union body, the TUC, to ban umbrella companies have been branded as 'misguided' and a 'knee jerk reaction' by representatives in the…BUSINESS
- 4 MAY 2021HMRC guidance on working through umbrella companies Recently PublishedFollowing a recent report from a Parliamentary group into umbrella companies, HMRC has published guidance explaining the role and function of…BUSINESS
- 20 APR 2021Call for Government action against unregulated umbrella companiesThe Government must take action to clean up the 'Wild West' supply chain that exploits freelance and contract workers and encourages tax avoidance…BUSINESS
- 25 MAR 2021LITRG report puts 'umbrella' companies under the spotlightThe Low Incomes Tax Reform Group (LITRG) has published a new research report looking at the use of 'umbrella' companies and other labour market…BUSINESS
- 23 DEC 2019IPSE: Welcome Loan Charge review but warning over IR35 endorsementFreelancer group, IPSE has welcomed the review into the Loan Charge by Sir Amyas Morse, although the group would have liked to have seen a move to…BUSINESS
- 14 AUG 2019Call to end 'war on contracting'The Prime Minister and Chancellor were called on to change course and end the 'war on contracting' by stopping the Loan Charge and the 'IR35'…IR35
- 25 JUN 2019Contracting sector calls for end to 'war on contracting'The contracting sector has called on the next Prime Minister to stop the Government's 'war on contracting' and instead support the UK's flexible…IR35
- 4 DEC 2018Lords Report a damning indictment of HMRC's treatment of taxpayersA House of Lords Report has concluded that HMRC abuses the extra powers it has been given to tackle tax evasion and avoidance.BUSINESS
- 13 AUG 2018Off-payroll consultation closes with the industry united against extension and the loan charge eight months awayThe consultation on extending the off-payroll rules to the private sector closed on Friday, and the responses that have been made public share one…IR35
- 5 AUG 2014HMRC close the net on offshore payment intermediariesThe change in legislation to place the compliance burden and tax/NI risk on recruitment agencies who pay their contractors via offshore payment…BUSINESS
- 18 JUL 2014Finance Act 2014 gives HMRC the power to demand disputed tax up frontThe Finance Act 2014 received Royal Assent on 17 July, and with it HMRC acquired the power that will define its relationship with tax avoidance for…BUSINESS
- 23 AUG 2005Revenue: EBTs, NIC and County courtsHM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) have issued a statement on their policy in connection with Employee Benefit Trusts, National Insurance contributions and…BUSINESS
- 5 OCT 2004Government accepts changes to small firms loan schemeThe Government has accepted the recommendations on the future of the Small Firms Loan Guarantee (SFLG) in the Teresa Graham report.BUSINESS
- 14 NOV 2002Expert analysis: Isle of Man IR35 avoidance strategy flawedA tax expert at independent tax consultancy firm WJB Chiltern has provided an analysis of a structure, currently being marketed as an IR35 avoidance…CONFERENCE PAPERS
